Chicago’s rental market moves fast. Scammers rely on that urgency—especially during peak months from May through September.
The Fake Roommate Scam
This usually starts with a friendly message.
A “roommate” claims they already live in a great apartment—often in Lakeview, Lincoln Park, Wicker Park, or Logan Square—and just need someone to take the second bedroom.
You’re shown photos. You’re quoted a rent that’s slightly below market. Then comes the hook:
“I’m out of town—just send a deposit to hold it.”
The apartment either doesn’t exist, or the scammer has no connection to it.
Common red flags:
- They won’t meet in person or do a live video walkthrough
- Excuses involving travel, military service, or family emergencies
- Pressure to send money before seeing the space
- Requests for Zelle, Cash App, Venmo, or gift cards
The Sublet That Isn’t Real
Sublet scams spike around internships, summer jobs, and short-term relocations.
A listing promises:
- Fully furnished
- Flexible lease
- Below-market rent
- Immediate availability
You’re told the landlord “already approved” the sublet. No paperwork is shown. Money is requested upfront.
Then the contact disappears—or worse, you show up to an apartment where the real tenant has never heard of you.
Real-World Chicago Examples
Example 1: The $1,100 Lakeview Bedroom
A renter responds to a Facebook post advertising a Lakeview East bedroom for $1,100—utilities included. Comparable rooms in that area usually run $1,300–$1,500.
The “roommate” asks for a $600 deposit before touring. After payment, the profile vanishes.
Example 2: The West Loop “Corporate Sublet”
A sublet is advertised at $1,700 for a West Loop one-bedroom—nearly $700 under market. The scammer provides a fake lease PDF and claims the building allows sublets freely.
In reality, many West Loop buildings strictly prohibit subletting without management approval.
Why These Scams Work So Well in Chicago
Competitive Rental Pressure
In desirable neighborhoods, legitimate listings receive dozens of inquiries within hours. Scammers exploit fear of missing out.
Trust in Peer-to-Peer Platforms
Facebook groups, Craigslist, and WhatsApp feel casual and community-driven—but they’re lightly moderated at best.
Lack of Paper Trails
Roommate agreements and sublets often happen informally, making it easier to bypass verification.
Chicago Pricing Reality Check
Use this as a quick sanity test.
Average roommate rents (2025 estimates):
- Lakeview / Lincoln Park: $1,300–$1,600
- Logan Square / Avondale: $1,000–$1,300
- West Loop / River North: $1,500–$1,900
If a listing is 20–30% below market, pause immediately.
How to Verify a Roommate or Sublet in Chicago
Step 1: Confirm Legal Authority
For sublets, ask for:
- Written landlord or property management approval
- A copy of the master lease (with sensitive info redacted)
- Confirmation of sublet terms in writing
Step 2: Verify the Address
Search the address online:
- Check Google Street View
- Look up property management companies
- Compare listing photos to past rental listings
Step 3: Tour the Unit—Live
Always insist on:
- In-person tours when possible
- Live video walkthroughs (not prerecorded)
- Seeing keys, common areas, and building signage
Step 4: Never Pay Before Verification
In Chicago, legitimate landlords and roommates do not require payment before a tour.
Platforms Where Chicago Scams Are Most Common
- Facebook Marketplace & housing groups
- Craigslist sublets section
- Telegram & WhatsApp housing chats
- Instagram DMs posing as “lease takeovers”
These platforms are not inherently bad—but verification is entirely on you.
What to Do If You’re Targeted or Scammed
- Stop communication immediately
- Save screenshots and payment records
- Report the listing to the platform
- File a report with the Chicago Police Department
- Warn others in local housing groups
Why Working With Verified Listings Matters
The safest way to avoid roommate and sublet scams is to start with verified inventory, clear pricing, and licensed professionals.
That’s where structured apartment touring and agent-verified listings make a difference—especially for renters relocating to Chicago or signing sight-unseen.
Summary: How Chicago Renters Stay Safe
- If it feels rushed, it’s a red flag
- Below-market rent usually means hidden risk
- Sublets require written landlord approval
- Never send money before touring
- Verified listings beat private DMs every time
Chicago is a great city. Finding housing here shouldn’t feel like a street hustle.
Visit TourWithAgent.com to schedule curated apartment tours in Chicago with real availability, real pricing, and an expert agent to guide you.
Related Articles-
Chicago Security Deposit Interest Rate Explained
Are Move-In Fees Refundable in Chicago?
Move In Fee vs Security Deposit in Chicago: What’s Better for Renters?
